I’ve been dealing with back and hip problems for decades, so the recent chapter of this story didn’t start with a dramatic collapse. It started the way these things usually do for me: another flare-up, another appointment, another attempt to find out whether medicine had anything left to offer that it hadn’t already tried. At eighty-one, with degenerative disc disease, arthritis, bursitis in both the back and hips, and spinal stenosis on top of it, I’ve had a lot of appointments — enough that I could probably draw the waiting room of any one of my specialists from memory. What’s different now isn’t the pain, and it isn’t the appointments themselves. It’s the question I’ve started asking myself before I let the front desk schedule the next one: will this actually give me more of the life I want to live, or am I just getting back on a ride I already know doesn’t go anywhere new. Somewhere in there is really the question of when to stop medical treatment — not permanently, not dramatically, just for now.
The specifics of my case turned out to be a fairly textbook example of what happens when a body doesn’t respect the boundaries doctors draw around their specialties. My back and my hip are connected in how I move, sit, and sleep, but medicine treats them as two separate problems belonging to two separate experts, and neither one particularly wants to step on the other’s toes. In my case there were actually three specialists involved, including a father-daughter pair who each handle injections. I’d go in, describe where the pain was worst that month, and come out with a plan aimed squarely at whichever joint that particular doctor treated — a plan that made sense on its own terms and often had little to say about the rest of me. Five different injections, across two different doctors, and no real relief that lasted. Each specialist was focused on fixing his or her own piece of the picture. Nobody stepped back to look at the whole one. I ended up the one holding all the pieces, comparing notes between appointments, trying to figure out on my own whether one doctor’s plan was working against another’s, with no clear sense of what to do with any of it.
There’s a term for part of what I was experiencing, though I didn’t know it until recently. Researchers who study the intensive care unit have coined the phrase clinical momentum to describe a strange, almost invisible force in modern medicine: once a course of treatment begins, it tends to keep going, test after test, procedure after procedure, simply because that’s the direction the system is already moving, not because anyone has stopped to ask whether it’s still the right direction. Nobody along my own path was acting in bad faith. Every one of those specialists genuinely wanted to help me, and each of them, in isolation, gave me perfectly reasonable advice. But the machinery of “try the next thing” has its own quiet momentum, and I found myself carried along by it for longer than I probably needed to be, agreeing to one more injection less because I expected it to work and more because it was simply the next scheduled thing to try.
The machinery of ‘try the next thing’ has its own quiet momentum, and I found myself carried along by it for longer than I probably needed to be.
The writer Katy Butler, who has spent years reporting on end-of-life medicine, describes something similar in blunter terms. American medicine, she argues, is extraordinary at throwing tests and treatments at problems that respond to a quick, decisive fix — an infection, a broken bone, an emergency. It’s far less equipped to handle the complicated, ongoing, no-clean-answer problems that don’t resolve so neatly, and that kind of “fast medicine,” applied to a slow problem, can create its own exhaustion. I’m not dying. My situation isn’t the one Butler usually writes about. But the same basic mismatch was playing out in miniature every time I sat down with another specialist hoping this appointment would be the one that actually changed something.
What I decided, eventually, wasn’t to give up on treatment permanently. It was to take a break. I want to be precise about that distinction, because it matters to me. I haven’t declared that I’m done with specialists, injections, or medical care for this. I’ve simply stopped scheduling the next appointment. Some of that is a genuine choice — a decision that the cycle of hope and disappointment had become its own kind of cost, separate from the physical pain itself. And some of it is an honest recognition that my options are narrower at eighty-one than they would have been at fifty. Surgery isn’t really on the table for me, and I’m not sure many doctors would encourage it even if I asked. Both things are true at once. I’m not interested in pretending it’s only one or the other.
That mixture, it turns out, isn’t unusual for people in my situation. A study of adults over seventy-five living with chronic pain found something I recognized immediately: most of them had come to expect limited improvement, and many had started to think of their pain as simply part of what growing older looks like, rather than a problem still actively waiting to be solved. That’s not resignation exactly. It’s closer to what I’ve done — a quiet recalibration of what counts as realistic, made by people who have already tried the reasonable things and are tired of being disappointed by the same hope over and over.
That’s really the heart of what pushed me to pause. It wasn’t the pain itself, though the pain is real and I manage it every day — I sleep comfortably on only one side now, and I take Meloxicam regularly, which limits what else I can safely take when things flare up. What I needed a break from was something more specific: the cycle of building hope before an appointment and having it quietly deflate afterward, five separate times, with two different doctors, and nothing to show for it. I’ve decided I don’t want to keep manufacturing that particular hope right now, only to have it disappointed again.
None of this means the pain doesn’t shape my days. Bonnie and I live downtown and love walking to restaurants and clubs together, and lately I’ve had to scale that back. The decision of whether to walk somewhere or call a ride-share gets made in the moment, standing at the door, weighing whatever the evening is worth against what I’ll likely feel the next morning. Some nights the answer is obvious — we walk, and I don’t think twice about it. Other nights I already know, before I’ve even asked myself the question, that the ride-share is the right call. That’s not a new way of thinking for me — I’ve been making some version of that trade-off for decades, long before this particular flare-up. What’s changed isn’t the math. It’s simply that the math has gotten harder, and the specialists haven’t been able to make it easier.
Bonnie, who’s seventy-nine and managing her own health issues, is generally agreeable to whatever I decide on a given night. I don’t think that’s indifference on her part. I think it’s two people who’ve each learned, in their own bodies, that some trade-offs don’t have a clean answer, and that the person living inside the pain is usually the one best positioned to weigh it.
I don’t know if I’ll go back to another specialist next year, or next month, or ever. I’m genuinely not deciding that today, and I don’t think I need to. What I’ve actually decided is smaller and, I think, more honest: that I’m allowed to stop chasing a fix for a while without that meaning I’ve given up, and that a pause isn’t the same thing as a verdict. Medicine has real, considerable power to help me, and I haven’t closed the door on it. I’ve just stepped back from a momentum that was carrying me forward without my full consent, to ask, in my own time, whether the next step is actually worth taking — or whether it’s simply the next stop on a ride I already know too well. Knowing when to stop medical treatment, at least for now, turned out to be less a single decision than a habit of asking the question honestly, appointment by appointment, for as long as it takes.


























